SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
91
91
May 8, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 91
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: i modify my motion. i'm not going to repeat the motion, but where applicable, on the record, we have talked about, conditional uses or whenever, i'm going to move what has been mentioned and agreed upon. we will sever 2a, adoption findings of ceqa. >> so you're taking this separately at this point? the motion is for item 2a, the adoption of ceqa findings. on the motion to adopt ceqa findings. commissioner antonini: aye. commissioner borden: aye. commissioner miguel: aye. commissioner moore: no. commissioner sugaya: aye. president fong: aye. >> the motion passes. commissioner antonini: now we move to 2b, st. louis general plan amendment. -- st. luke's general plan amendment. >> did someone have their microphone -- on the motion to approve -- recommend approval to the board of supervisors the general plan amendment to the st. luke's campus. commissioner antonini: aye. commissioner borden: aye. commissioner miguel: aye. commissioner moore: aye. commissioner sugaya: aye. president fong: aye. >> the motion pa
commissioner antonini: i modify my motion. i'm not going to repeat the motion, but where applicable, on the record, we have talked about, conditional uses or whenever, i'm going to move what has been mentioned and agreed upon. we will sever 2a, adoption findings of ceqa. >> so you're taking this separately at this point? the motion is for item 2a, the adoption of ceqa findings. on the motion to adopt ceqa findings. commissioner antonini: aye. commissioner borden: aye. commissioner miguel:...
commissioner antonini: ok.
SFGTV2: San Francisco Government Television
135
135
May 3, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV2
tv
eye 135
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: ok. the surface, we will allow that to buy cu, a temporary use for five years. the same thing with the washington-broadway sud, the same kind of provision with a five-year renewal. >> that is our recommendation. commissioner antonini: it seems consistent that we are not in here every two years. i realize we want to get them out of having parking lots, but it might be a little too much process. >> you would want them to be prohibited in the washington- broadway sud? and have to come back five years? commissioner antonini: we do want them to be allowed by cu, but every five years instead of every two years. >> they do not have to come back. if you take staff's recommendation, they are conditionally permiteted. commissioner antonini: maybe we will go with status condition on that. i am a little confused, but that would be fined. -- fine. i believe that is all that, if i am not mistaken. ok. commissioner moore: while we are moving to support you and the legislation, i would still ask about th
commissioner antonini: ok. the surface, we will allow that to buy cu, a temporary use for five years. the same thing with the washington-broadway sud, the same kind of provision with a five-year renewal. >> that is our recommendation. commissioner antonini: it seems consistent that we are not in here every two years. i realize we want to get them out of having parking lots, but it might be a little too much process. >> you would want them to be prohibited in the washington- broadway...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
89
89
May 8, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 89
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: ok, good. of this group, we are saying that no less than 40 will have to be san francisco residents. and i think coming from situations such as the health care cut -- academy or the community benefits organizations. >> correct. the 40 that i am focus on of that 100 is mostly in entry- level health care. so there might be other kinds of areas of, not so much health care, but entry level that is not captured, but we would still work with cpmc to capture as many additional entry level as we could. it is just the focus is really on entry-level health care to really move that, because that is a growing sector here, a booming sector. commissioner antonini: we also have another 1500 new jobs projected to be created, permanent jobs, over 10 years, of which we are saying 222 will be entry level under the previous qualifier or about 22 per year. that is above and beyond the ones we talked about in the attrition situation. >> correct. yes. commissioner antonini: ok, good. the other thing i want to point o
commissioner antonini: ok, good. of this group, we are saying that no less than 40 will have to be san francisco residents. and i think coming from situations such as the health care cut -- academy or the community benefits organizations. >> correct. the 40 that i am focus on of that 100 is mostly in entry- level health care. so there might be other kinds of areas of, not so much health care, but entry level that is not captured, but we would still work with cpmc to capture as many...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
69
69
May 13, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 69
favorite 0
quote 0
icommissioner antonini: this is an issue that i see. the second part of my question is in regards to the lower deck of the bottom level home. it has already come in 3 feet, i would like to see it come in 6 inches to minimize it a little more and answer some of the concerns that the adjacent neighbors -- may be round the corners a little bit. you still have a good-sized pack. >> we offered that at one point. -- you have a good sized deck. >> i was told of privacy was what he wanted, he could do a privacy screen and put bars of his daughters window. that's what he said to me. commissioner antonini: that is something i would be interested in looking into. my only other thing on the upper one is we have one of the situations where views are not protected either way. it's up to the commission to decide where the location is going to be and we don't want to put it in a place that takes the view into consideration. hi have some ideas on a compromise. -- i have some ideas on a compromise. thank you. commissioner miguel: just to clarify, althoug
icommissioner antonini: this is an issue that i see. the second part of my question is in regards to the lower deck of the bottom level home. it has already come in 3 feet, i would like to see it come in 6 inches to minimize it a little more and answer some of the concerns that the adjacent neighbors -- may be round the corners a little bit. you still have a good-sized pack. >> we offered that at one point. -- you have a good sized deck. >> i was told of privacy was what he wanted,...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
62
62
May 5, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 62
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: there is not a back in these plans. any future plan -- that is an understanding. it does not have to be a condition, but it is an understanding. commissioner moore: i would like to remind the applicant that much of what has been going on here could have been avoided if you, after the first continuation, would have made a more concerted effort to describe the existing and proposed conditions with drawings which are appropriate to what this commission approves. then the misunderstanding about size of windows would have been properly addressed. should you ever apply another property for do something similarly, i would strongly advise you to work with a group of professionals who can help you deliver this in a more communicable language other than words. this is not about words. it is architecture. it has to do with physical design and understanding the circumstance of what is going on. there are no color revisions, no discussion about material, except asking for the granite curb, which leaves a lot of mistakes to be made.
commissioner antonini: there is not a back in these plans. any future plan -- that is an understanding. it does not have to be a condition, but it is an understanding. commissioner moore: i would like to remind the applicant that much of what has been going on here could have been avoided if you, after the first continuation, would have made a more concerted effort to describe the existing and proposed conditions with drawings which are appropriate to what this commission approves. then the...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
71
71
May 13, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 71
favorite 0
quote 0
>> commissioner antonini. commissioner antonini: thank you. once again, we saw some tragic events with the fire in dubos this week. i have made some suggestions in the past, and i probably should take this up with some of the supervisors, and perhaps at least with the planning staff in more detail about some sort of incentives with people with older, seismically structured lee -- seismically, structurally, allegedly compromised units to be able to renovate these to bring them up to taper standards. i have suggested in the past looking at some kind of situation where some sort of trade may be possible with newer units that have fewer of these challenges, and are probably less expensive to maintain and, certainly, do not need the amount of maintenance that the older units do. there may be a way to do some kind of trade to make you -- a newer units permanently affordable, rent controls, in exchange for allowing the older units to be able to change their configuration, sell them, rent them. but i think it would be a net benefit for the city to hav
>> commissioner antonini. commissioner antonini: thank you. once again, we saw some tragic events with the fire in dubos this week. i have made some suggestions in the past, and i probably should take this up with some of the supervisors, and perhaps at least with the planning staff in more detail about some sort of incentives with people with older, seismically structured lee -- seismically, structurally, allegedly compromised units to be able to renovate these to bring them up to taper...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
97
97
May 19, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 97
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: i too read the letter from the hpc. i am in agreement with a lot of what is stated in there. the design concerns they have with the replacement structure in no way has any impact on the adequacy, accuracy, or completeness of the eir, which is, of course, all of those things. they make some points the we have to look at as we go forward. of course, we do have all of the necessary alternatives, including the parcel preservation project, the preferred project. we have a lot of things to choose from. of course, that will move forward at a later time. as far as the report itself, it seems to be quite thorough. commissioner miguel: to follow up on commissioner wu's comments, particularly on page s-21 of the tdm comments, i think there were very well thought out. much more detail than we usually see in an eir. i was pleased to see that. on the variant, when you get in, i think it is a roman numeral ii -- the off-street parking i would fully agree with. i think it is a good use of the space, it can work, and it should definitel
commissioner antonini: i too read the letter from the hpc. i am in agreement with a lot of what is stated in there. the design concerns they have with the replacement structure in no way has any impact on the adequacy, accuracy, or completeness of the eir, which is, of course, all of those things. they make some points the we have to look at as we go forward. of course, we do have all of the necessary alternatives, including the parcel preservation project, the preferred project. we have a lot...
SFGTV2: San Francisco Government Television
112
112
May 24, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV2
tv
eye 112
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: thank you. commissioner wu: i would like to ask a question to understand what this eir would cover compared to what might be covered in the future. in most interested in shadows, but what i think you were saying just now that has not been decided was whether the impact would be looked at cumulatively versus building by building, but if you could describe to me what analysis -- environmental analysis will be done if this eir is passed -- what analysis will be done on each of the individual buildings. >> i can tell you what is the untypically. this is a programmatic eir, so it is looking at what could potentially occur under the proposed zoning changes. it is not looking at individual building proposals. so what we would intend to do is in exploring each individual building, we will do specific shadow studies to identify the changes in shadow square-foot hours that would occur on each part, so that is how we would analyze shadow for any individual buildings. the expectation is that any individual
commissioner antonini: thank you. commissioner wu: i would like to ask a question to understand what this eir would cover compared to what might be covered in the future. in most interested in shadows, but what i think you were saying just now that has not been decided was whether the impact would be looked at cumulatively versus building by building, but if you could describe to me what analysis -- environmental analysis will be done if this eir is passed -- what analysis will be done on each...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
109
109
May 19, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 109
favorite 0
quote 0
president fong: commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: i want to thank commissioner wu for requesting never get zoning maps for first meetings. it has been very helpful and i have enough space in my office to actually put it out. i have asked to talk to secretary avery and by the she has talked to director ram about it, i hearing in the future where we could have -- about a hearing in the future where we could have a discussion about the zoning categories for the benefit of the commissioners and for the public. i think there are questions that would come up and it would make it easier for people to understand what is going on what we are discussing these differences of what is an nc and what isa ct and there are also a lot of special use districts. i think it would be helpful during one of our sessions to go over that. that is what i would suggest calendaring and i would like to see if we have agreement with the other commissioners along those lines. i do not need an answer right now, but the other two things i want
president fong: commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: i want to thank commissioner wu for requesting never get zoning maps for first meetings. it has been very helpful and i have enough space in my office to actually put it out. i have asked to talk to secretary avery and by the she has talked to director ram about it, i hearing in the future where we could have -- about a hearing in the future where we could have a discussion about the zoning categories for the benefit of the...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
161
161
May 4, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 161
favorite 0
quote 0
president fong: commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: staff is recommending against the changes or against the provision entirely? it was a change that was going to allow it to be 100 feet from the corner and increase the square footage. >> we are recommending against the change to the legislation as it is currently drafted, because we made the commitment to the community that we would not change it for five years, and would go through a review process. in response to that, the supervisor has agreed to leave the market octavia parcel alone, but changed it in other districts, which i think our -- are rm-3, and some other south of market. he is deciding to increase it to 100 feet from the corner and 2500 sq. feet for all the lccu's that are not in the market octavia plan. commissioner antonini: and that is all right with staff? >> it is better than the original. we would like it thrown out, but if that is a compromise -- commissioner antonini: or we could not approve and leave it as it is. >> you could just not do it
president fong: commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: staff is recommending against the changes or against the provision entirely? it was a change that was going to allow it to be 100 feet from the corner and increase the square footage. >> we are recommending against the change to the legislation as it is currently drafted, because we made the commitment to the community that we would not change it for five years, and would go through a review process. in response to that, the...
SFGTV2: San Francisco Government Television
128
128
May 17, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV2
tv
eye 128
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: that is based on square footage? >> it depends on the use, but generally, yes. it is being replaced by maximum parking controls, which it depends on the use. section 151.1, it goes over the uses and tells you the minimum and maximum. commissioner antonini: staff feels that was consistent with what we have in other areas, densely populated retail areas such as downtown? >> yes. commissioner antonini: i do not have as much a problem about that. i am concerned about the van ness corridor. also, the cr districts, which were called out earlier. van ness has the van ness sud. as we heard with the hearing with cal pacific, there is three times the amount of residential- to-commercial. therefore, it is sometimes difficult to make topencil out. i am not saying that most of the development might be against having an interest in having less parking. there may be situations along the van ness corridor where some of the buildings would be residential, for sale, or even for rent, that would be of a scope that, to make this thing w
commissioner antonini: that is based on square footage? >> it depends on the use, but generally, yes. it is being replaced by maximum parking controls, which it depends on the use. section 151.1, it goes over the uses and tells you the minimum and maximum. commissioner antonini: staff feels that was consistent with what we have in other areas, densely populated retail areas such as downtown? >> yes. commissioner antonini: i do not have as much a problem about that. i am concerned...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
106
106
May 8, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 106
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: and we combine that with housing since it is sort of related to? questions and comments, we were asked about the special use district, and i guess this is a question or comment for director lee. you know, we are allowed by conditional use, as an institution, it is not obliged to provide a three times the housing to commercial. but i think everyone pretty much felt that there should be some contribution to the housing particularly because of the impact. what we came up with his $62 million plan here which is significant, provides more housing ultimately that would be the case of using this very clever and very useful addressing middle income housing. the first time, i can remember where we targeted the group that we are having the middle income housing, i know the plan exists on downpayment assistance. it addresses their impact that probably will be significant. we're talking about 6200 existing jobs turning over at the rate of 400-600 a year, projecting 1500 new ones over 10 or 15 years. 15% of the workers live in san francisco now. the reason to b
commissioner antonini: and we combine that with housing since it is sort of related to? questions and comments, we were asked about the special use district, and i guess this is a question or comment for director lee. you know, we are allowed by conditional use, as an institution, it is not obliged to provide a three times the housing to commercial. but i think everyone pretty much felt that there should be some contribution to the housing particularly because of the impact. what we came up...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
77
77
May 1, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 77
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner sugaya: i apologize, commissioner antonini, for jumping in there. anyway, i still go back to my -- it is going to be a comment. that is all. my other argument that the city should have negotiated for the 73 million in the first place. then we could have decided how to divide it up, whether it would have been 29 still for the assistance program and the rest for building housing or whatever it is. i still do not understand why we are dropping below that number. also, it bothers me, as commissioner moore has said, that it is specifically targeted to cpmc employees. we had testimony from the man from the hotel who said his business was going to increase, he will be spending additional money, he expects to have 10-15 new employees. there is the nexus, right? it is not just not cpmc employees. everybody says this will be ed -- a big economic engine for the area. multiple new jobs created by these kinds of businesses. he is saying people are going to the restaurant and eat at cafes so more jobs will be created. none of these people are going to qualify for
commissioner sugaya: i apologize, commissioner antonini, for jumping in there. anyway, i still go back to my -- it is going to be a comment. that is all. my other argument that the city should have negotiated for the 73 million in the first place. then we could have decided how to divide it up, whether it would have been 29 still for the assistance program and the rest for building housing or whatever it is. i still do not understand why we are dropping below that number. also, it bothers me,...
SFGTV2: San Francisco Government Television
94
94
May 18, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV2
tv
eye 94
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: thank you. it seems to me that the entire issue here comes around the rear part of the proposed home addition which involves the second and third floors, being the two bedrooms for the children on the second floor and the master bath predominantly on the third floor. there is a 3 foot setback and has been -- as has been pointed out which is fairly standard. not the entire house is set back 3 feet but even in rh-1 detached homes you do not see more than 3 feet per side. that is fairly standard. however, in terms of making some concessions, i do not really see where you can take the two bedrooms and more because on the second floor, it was pointed out there are 10 by 12 which are fairly modest sized bedrooms. if you took 2 feet off from those you would end up with -- you could move the ball over and you would end up with mud -- nine by 12. that would only gain you the 2 ft. but it would be fairly small. the master bathroom -- maybe i can talk to the architect or the project sponsor. would seem to
commissioner antonini: thank you. it seems to me that the entire issue here comes around the rear part of the proposed home addition which involves the second and third floors, being the two bedrooms for the children on the second floor and the master bath predominantly on the third floor. there is a 3 foot setback and has been -- as has been pointed out which is fairly standard. not the entire house is set back 3 feet but even in rh-1 detached homes you do not see more than 3 feet per side....
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
68
68
May 27, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 68
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: a couple of other points. what i think during testimony moved me the most was the fact that a number of groups came up and said the choice for them was not between natural turf and artificial turf. that was between at any kind of turf and the pavement. they had to play on pavement because there are so few fields. i think this is important to keep in mind as we move forward. we also found that we have kids in san francisco, contrary to what has been pointed out. we have a lot of them, and they are very articulate and they're learning about public process. one other thing that came out, has been brought up in testimony, is whether or not you need to analyze the alternatives. according to ceqa, we do not have to do that. there are four alternatives taken up in the eir, which is in regards to this project itself. but you do not have to analyze an entirely different project to conform with ceqa. so while that is an interesting concept, although i think the light will have more impact on a greater number of people i
commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: a couple of other points. what i think during testimony moved me the most was the fact that a number of groups came up and said the choice for them was not between natural turf and artificial turf. that was between at any kind of turf and the pavement. they had to play on pavement because there are so few fields. i think this is important to keep in mind as we move forward. we also found that we have kids in san francisco, contrary to what has been...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
100
100
May 1, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 100
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: sounds reasonable to me. there are a couple things that i would include at this point. those are my main point on transportation, i believe. it was the part of the transportation demand management plan. commissioner borden: i am glad that he brought that up because i was going to bring that out. i know that all that kind of stuff has been discussed. i think we can include the language about looking at the construction drawings, they are being called in the cu portion. the conditions of approval the create the communities -- >> it was to expand this idea of the community and advisory group. what they are doing for the davis campus for the construction when they have final contest and construction plan. >> it is a final document, that is why they wanted the draft version to review to that they can critique it before it comes final. it is kind of an ongoing and fluid process. commissioner borden: it will also circulate that same kind of document. >> you will be including these in the motion that the advisor regr
commissioner antonini: sounds reasonable to me. there are a couple things that i would include at this point. those are my main point on transportation, i believe. it was the part of the transportation demand management plan. commissioner borden: i am glad that he brought that up because i was going to bring that out. i know that all that kind of stuff has been discussed. i think we can include the language about looking at the construction drawings, they are being called in the cu portion. the...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
84
84
May 19, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 84
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini, aye. commissioner borden, aye, commissioner miguel, aye, commissioner sugaya, aye, commissioner wu, aye. the motion passes unanimously. >> think you for your work and patience. -- thank you for your work and your patience. >> you are now on item 13. case no. 2011.1439dd for 2539 vallejo street. >> the case before you is a staff initiated discretionary review as well as a neighborhood initiated discretionary review. this is a late submission from the d.r. requestor which is the alternative proposal. it was submitted after that deadline. i am passing it out now. the subject property is on the south side of alito -- vallejo street. there is a single family residence. it is 40% of a lot. the existing building has no set aside. it slopes
commissioner antonini, aye. commissioner borden, aye, commissioner miguel, aye, commissioner sugaya, aye, commissioner wu, aye. the motion passes unanimously. >> think you for your work and patience. -- thank you for your work and your patience. >> you are now on item 13. case no. 2011.1439dd for 2539 vallejo street. >> the case before you is a staff initiated discretionary review as well as a neighborhood initiated discretionary review. this is a late submission from the d.r....
SFGTV2: San Francisco Government Television
88
88
May 24, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV2
tv
eye 88
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: thank you. the question has not been asked, but one that is obvious is with the construction of the transit tower and the accompanying towers, there will be a tremendous amount of new commercial space provided. will the demand be there? contrary to what is sometimes commented, in reviewing the fortune 500, san francisco has seven of the 500 companies, which does not sound like a lot, but it is far more than any other city in california, which has 53. the nearest in california is los angeles with four. we also have more headquarters in chicago and philadelphia, and, of course, indianapolis, jacksonville, cleveland, pittsburgh, and a myriad of cities. the other thing that is important is that because of the emphasis on climate control and sustainability, there will be an interest in people living closer to where they worked. i commented on the book the great in version that is very interesting. the thesis is that people are choosing to live in center cities again throughout the world, and this has
commissioner antonini: thank you. the question has not been asked, but one that is obvious is with the construction of the transit tower and the accompanying towers, there will be a tremendous amount of new commercial space provided. will the demand be there? contrary to what is sometimes commented, in reviewing the fortune 500, san francisco has seven of the 500 companies, which does not sound like a lot, but it is far more than any other city in california, which has 53. the nearest in...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
94
94
May 6, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 94
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: maybe we will go with status condition on that. i am a little confused, but that would be fined. -- fine. i believe that is all that, if i am not mistaken. ok. commissioner moore: while we are moving to support you and the legislation, i would still ask about the documents will be checked one more time for consistency in terms of how words and dates and issues are looked at as part of what we are considering today. i still see the reference to bte waterfront special use district in there. that is the front page of the draft resolution. you are capturing the majority of your recommendations, but i want to make sure that you go through this. >> i will be happy to do this. i usually listen to the hearing again. on the front part, that is the entire legislation and. that is the standard way we do it. commissioner moore: i do not see any reference to phase 2. >> when you get to the whereas's, it specifies what phase 2 is. on page two, all the way down at the bottom. commissioner moore: i am asking you to just check it one more time. tha
commissioner antonini: maybe we will go with status condition on that. i am a little confused, but that would be fined. -- fine. i believe that is all that, if i am not mistaken. ok. commissioner moore: while we are moving to support you and the legislation, i would still ask about the documents will be checked one more time for consistency in terms of how words and dates and issues are looked at as part of what we are considering today. i still see the reference to bte waterfront special use...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
97
97
May 1, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 97
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: thank you. commissioner moore: while you're there, would you clarify for me, with these 40 people, is it over five years or 40 -- or 40 per year over five years? >> 40 per year over five years, for a total of 200. commissioner moore: ok, thank you. >> commissioners, any questions related to the topic of housing? commissioner borden: i just wanted to be clear on one program. you said when the money is paid back because of the natural attrition and people pay off the loans, with that money go back to the general program for all of san francisco, not just into a program for cpmc employees? >> the repayment would go into a general fund at the mayor's office, and we would invest that in rental housing. the transaction is broken up into two affordable housing components. one for the traditional affordable housing, primarily rental housing, and then the cpmc downpayment assistance program. when somebody sells their unit and we received our principal plus a share of appreciation, we'll take those procee
commissioner antonini: thank you. commissioner moore: while you're there, would you clarify for me, with these 40 people, is it over five years or 40 -- or 40 per year over five years? >> 40 per year over five years, for a total of 200. commissioner moore: ok, thank you. >> commissioners, any questions related to the topic of housing? commissioner borden: i just wanted to be clear on one program. you said when the money is paid back because of the natural attrition and people pay...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
71
71
May 6, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 71
favorite 0
quote 0
president fong: commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: staff is recommending against the changes or against the provision entirely? it was a change that was going to allow it to be 100 feet from the corner and increase the square footage. >> we are recommending against the change to the legislation as it is currently drafted, because we made the commitment to the community that we would not change it for five years, and would go through a review process. in response to that, the supervisor has agreed to leave the market octavia parcel alone, but changed it in other districts, which i think our -- are rm-3,
president fong: commissioner antonini? commissioner antonini: staff is recommending against the changes or against the provision entirely? it was a change that was going to allow it to be 100 feet from the corner and increase the square footage. >> we are recommending against the change to the legislation as it is currently drafted, because we made the commitment to the community that we would not change it for five years, and would go through a review process. in response to that, the...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
93
93
May 1, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 93
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini. commissioner antonini: ok, let's see. the first thing i had was in regards to the issue of charitable care which i believe falls into our category here. again, there is representation made about the amount that is being pledged and the fact that it was lower than the year before. well, this is an average of the three years and the $86 million is a floor. it does not include the additional 10,000 medical recipients that will have to be cared for by california pacific as part of the dream, at least 1,500 of which come from the tenderloin and then $20 million to the tenderloin community care innovation fund. as audited fanning has point the out, the charitable things they are doing, the hepb and c and the chinese hospital contributions and multitude of others and other very comparable, from my research looking at other hospitals within san francisco and outside of san francisco, very comparable in terms of charitable care. that's not actually a statement, not a question, but if you disagree with me, certainly, you have anyth
commissioner antonini. commissioner antonini: ok, let's see. the first thing i had was in regards to the issue of charitable care which i believe falls into our category here. again, there is representation made about the amount that is being pledged and the fact that it was lower than the year before. well, this is an average of the three years and the $86 million is a floor. it does not include the additional 10,000 medical recipients that will have to be cared for by california pacific as...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
54
54
May 4, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 54
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: some of these sound like they have to be as submitted. that is obvious. >> just so you know, this is the first time i have seen this. number one, that is fine. they should do what they are going to say in the drawings anyway. property line windows on the second floor shove the fire rated, and as required by code the non-opening and opaque. property line windows have to be fire-rated. i do not think fire-rated windows can be openable. perhaps cross fat off. -- cross that of. -- off. commissioner antonini: just take the opaque part of. >> the upper living room will not be used as a deck. it is not shown as such on the drawings. commissioner miguel: i see no reason why they could not have a legal deck. >> ok. take that off. the doctor shall be added to the second floor. that is not really -- the gutter shall be added to the second floor. that is not really a planning issue. the proposed west elevation is seeking to do a clear story -- clerestory window, the property window. commissioner miguel: does it have to be opaque? >> that is your call
commissioner antonini: some of these sound like they have to be as submitted. that is obvious. >> just so you know, this is the first time i have seen this. number one, that is fine. they should do what they are going to say in the drawings anyway. property line windows on the second floor shove the fire rated, and as required by code the non-opening and opaque. property line windows have to be fire-rated. i do not think fire-rated windows can be openable. perhaps cross fat off. -- cross...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
91
91
May 26, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 91
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: what is really before us at this particular time is certification. the eir, which is a complete, accurate and very analytical extension, and so really, that is the only issue we are considering in this particular motion right now, which i will move to certify the environmental impact report. >> second. commissioner wu: i do think that the eir -- it does an adequate job of addressing shadow and hats. it describes that there is an impact. it describes what the shuttle impact is. it does not diminish the importance of sunshine, but i also feel that voting to certify the eir is sort of an implicit statement about shadows. what i want to say is that i really think a shadow ordinance is important, and i do not want take for granted that through one action, you are sort of implying that all these other actions will be easy or that they will follow in that way. i just think that -- i want to make clear that despite -- or acknowledging that acknowledgingeir itself -- acknowledging that the eir itself is adequate, that these are issues to be considered on anot
commissioner antonini: what is really before us at this particular time is certification. the eir, which is a complete, accurate and very analytical extension, and so really, that is the only issue we are considering in this particular motion right now, which i will move to certify the environmental impact report. >> second. commissioner wu: i do think that the eir -- it does an adequate job of addressing shadow and hats. it describes that there is an impact. it describes what the shuttle...
SFGTV: San Francisco Government Television
97
97
May 6, 2012
05/12
by
SFGTV
tv
eye 97
favorite 0
quote 0
commissioner antonini: aye. commissioner miguel: aye. commissioner sugaya: aye. president fong: aye. commissioner wu: aye. you are now on item number 11. the transit center district plan. these are for initiation. initiation of amendment to the general plan. initiation of the amendment to the planning code. initiation of amendment to the zoning map. commissioner sugaya: i have to ask the board for accuse so. i did -- recusant. i did discuss this with the city attorney's office. because the firm i worked on and worked on the survey, which resulted in information being used any environmental impact report, back in that same situation i was with the eastern neighborhoods plan and market october yet -- market octavia. that was because of the participation, i am conflicted on the eir. until the eir is certified, i cannot participate in the discussion on the zoning aspects of the transit center plan. once it has been certified, without my participation, i am free to participate in this aspect of the deliberations. >> motion for accusal. >> motion to recuse commissioner
commissioner antonini: aye. commissioner miguel: aye. commissioner sugaya: aye. president fong: aye. commissioner wu: aye. you are now on item number 11. the transit center district plan. these are for initiation. initiation of amendment to the general plan. initiation of the amendment to the planning code. initiation of amendment to the zoning map. commissioner sugaya: i have to ask the board for accuse so. i did -- recusant. i did discuss this with the city attorney's office. because the firm...